Whether it be the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire that in 1911 took the lives of 146 most young immigrant women, or the Flatbush Ave. collapse that killed eight including two construction workers, there are the proximate causes like a locked door or flawed excavation and then there are the broader systemic issues that also need examination.
Was the excavation site a union site, non-union or mixed? A firm answer has yet to emerge but it very much matters.
A spokesperson for the Building and Construction Trades Council of Greater New York said the group was "fairly certain" the Brooklyn site was non-union.
According to the latest annual report by the New York Committee on Occupational Safety & Health, over 80 percent of the construction deaths in 2024 in New York State were on non-union worksites. Multiple peer reviewed studies have confirmed that union construction jobs are safer thanks to training workforce stability and retention.
In New York City, according to an analysis done by New York State Comptroller Tom DiNapoli, 61 percent of the construction jobs were held by immigrants, whose immigration status can be leveraged by unscrupulous employers.
"Worker safety is public safety," the Building and Construction Trades Council said in a statement.
"Although the investigation into this particular incident is ongoing, it should be emphasized that implementation and adequately funded agency enforcement of safety standards on construction sites and connected buildings must be of the utmost priority, not only for the sake of the workers on the job, but also for the surrounding community that could be directly affected by any accidents or failures that occur.
After mass casualty events like the Flatbush Ave. collapse in Brooklyn responding FDNY units do what's called a "hot wash" so that the responding units can learn from their performance while the experience is fresh in their memory. Emergency response is a team pursuit with the objective being the preservation of life--the life of fellow first responders and the general public whose very existence can often be hanging by a thread.
Rather than deflecting, bureaucracies like the Department of Buildings, upon which so much depends, need to do something similar.
Several other Flatbush Ave. addresses had to also be evacuated as a consequence of the collapse that's also damning evidence of the long-standing systemic failure of the City of New York to regulate in any meaningful way the real estate and construction companies. These industries spread massive amounts of campaign cash around in Washington, Albany and in New York City.
Multiple news outlets have already documented the reality that the mixed residential and commercial building that collapsed, and the adjacent excavation site into which it collapsed, had checkered histories that should have served as a red flag for the Department of Buildings.
For a generation now, going back decades the city has relied on self-certification from private sector professional engineers. At the same time, the percentage of construction work being done by more accountable union shops has declined.
"Since its expansion five years ago, self-certification has been cited--sometimes by a stretch of the definition--as an underlying cause of collapsed facades, chronic corruption and homeowners left stranded with slipshod construction and no permanent certificates of occupancy," the New York Times reported in December of 2000.
Scroll forward to 2026, and as New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin recently noted, the DOB is missing nine percent of its authorized workforce post COVID.
It appears that the Mamdani administration is scrambling to get ahead of the curve by investigating the companies involved with the Flatbush re-development.
"A tragedy of this magnitude demands an investigation that includes both the construction site and the building which collapsed," Mamdani told reporters. "That has already begun with the Department of Buildings and law enforcement leading it. We will find out what happened and we will share that information with New Yorkers There are five main entities involved with this construction site or are associated with approximately 100 other sites across the city. Our Department of Buildings is commencing sweeps of the sites today."
City officials did their best to lay out a coherent narrative that raised more questions than it answered.
"The type of work they were conducting was excavation work on that job site. And so, that was what they were working on today," Department of Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani, told reporters. "They have a plan approved for a three-story building, but they have current plans looking for a nine-story building, which has not yet been approved for. At this point, all we have at this time is excavation work in that section of the construction site."
"The development team behind the property had previously ignored a stop-work order earlier in the year, city records show," reported the Gothamist. "The absence of the bracing raises further questions about the safety of the construction work."
The Gothmaist continued. "Three structural engineers who reviewed the engineering documents, known as 'support of excavation' plans, said they were surprised to see that the buildings department approved the measures without the additional structural support, which can help prevent adjoining buildings from collapsing when excavation work is done."
It was just a few months back that union workers, working on a mixed site, flagged structural deficiencies at the former Pfizer office tower that was in the midst of being converted into a luxury apartment building. The building had to be evacuated because the FDNY and the Department of Buildings determined it was at risk of collapsing because steel structural supports on the 21st floor had been bent in half under the weight of the upper floors.
The evacuation extended to other buildings including a hotel in the area that includes Grand Central Station.
The ambitious office space to residential conversion project, the largest of its kind in the nation, was a so-called "open shop" where non-union and union workers function side by side. On Frontline Voices Frenchie Davis spoke with Sean Dow, a shop steward with Steamfitters Local 638, who discovered the bent columns and reported them to his foreman that sparked the evacuation.
Union advocates say the proliferation of non-union construction, particularly in the residential sector, puts both workers and the public at risk because non-union, often undocumented workers are afraid of speaking up about conditions that can exist, like at the former Pfizer building.
As is being done post Flatbush collapse, the Mamdani administration had the DOB review 180 active sites linked to the professionals responsible for the Pfizer conversion. That review resulted in 62 violations and 18 stop worker orders being issued.
In a city where cash is king and time is money, we have seen corruption reach the very highest levels of the FDNY and the Department of Buildings upon which so much day to day regulation relies.
Two years ago, Brian Cordasco, the FDNY Chief in charge of Fire Prevention, pleaded guilty to accepting tens of thousands of dollars in bribes to expedite inspections.
"From 2021 to 2023, Cordasco repeatedly abused his position as a Chief of the BFP by participating in a scheme to solicit and receive $190,000 in total bribe payments from a former FDNY firefighter named Henry Santiago, Jr.," according to federal prosecutors. "In exchange for those bribe payments, Cordasco used his authority within the BFP to improperly 'expedite' BFP inspections and plan reviews for Santiago’s customers. Cordasco personally profited $57,000 as part of this scheme. To carry out this conspiracy, Cordasco lied to his BFP subordinates to justify otherwise improper expediting requests. Cordasco also lied to law enforcement when interviewed about his involvement in the scheme."
Back in 2023 former Department of Buildings Commissioner Eric Ulrich was indicted.
"We allege that Eric Ulrich accepted or solicited more than $150,000 worth of bribes in less than two years by monetizing each elected and appointed role he held in New York City government," wrote Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg in a statement. "At every possible turn, he allegedly used his taxpayer-funded positions as City Councilmember, then Senior Mayoral Advisor, and finally Department of Buildings Commissioner to line his pockets. Government officials must abide by the law and uphold their duty to the People of New York. Particularly when a public servant runs an agency that affects the lives of millions – from residents of apartments to the workers that build them – we must hold them to the highest standard."
There can come a point where the lack of compliance, or looking the other way, crosses over from being a civil violation or a fireable offense, to a case worthy of criminal prosecution.
Such was the case a decade ago when a general contractor Harco Construction LLC was found guilty in the 2015 trench collapse death of 22-year-old immigrant construction worker Carlos Moncayo who was working in a 13-foot-deep trench despite repeated warnings that the site was unsafe. The company was convicted of manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide.
The supervisor was sentenced to three years in jail and the company was fined $10,000.
